Should You Repair or Replace? A Homeowner’s Quick-Impact Guide

Sabhya Katia
November 3, 2025

Deciding whether to repair or replace can feel overwhelming—and costly if you guess wrong. Here’s a mid-length, actionable rundown to help you choose wisely, with data-backed PropIQ tips at every turn.

🏷️ Appliances (8–15 Years)

  • Repair: Minor fixes (clogged filters, broken switches) if under 10 years old.
  • Replace: Two or more repairs in a year, rising energy bills, or outdated efficiency.
  • 💡 PropIQ Tip: Old appliances can drag value by 1–2%. Check local comps in PropIQ before spending.

❄️ HVAC (15–20 Years)

  • Repair: One-off issues after routine maintenance.
  • Replace: Repair costs exceed 50% of unit value or chronic performance drops.
  • 💡 PropIQ Tip: Homes with new HVAC systems sell up to 5 days faster in extreme-weather markets.

🏠 Roof (20+ Years)

  • Repair: Isolated shingle damage or loose flashing.
  • Replace: Multiple leaks, sagging, or age past 20 years.
  • 💡 PropIQ Tip: New roofs recoup ~60–70% of cost at resale—PropIQ shows your neighborhood’s exact numbers.

🚪 Cabinets & Fixtures

  • Repair: Cosmetic issues—hinges, knobs, minor scratches.
  • Replace: Inefficient layouts or styles more than 15 years old.
  • 💡 PropIQ Tip: Cabinet refacing yields up to 2× ROI of full replacing in many zip codes.

🪟 Windows (20+ Years)

  • Repair: Single cracked panes or bad seals.
  • Replace: Drafts, fogging, or all windows over 20 years old.
  • 💡 PropIQ Tip: Energy-efficient windows can boost curb appeal and may qualify for tax credits—see local impact in PropIQ.

Bottom Line: Repair to save short-term—replace to build long-term equity.👉 Run the numbers with PropIQ before you decide

Your Customers Are Your Best Leads

Turn intent signals into meaningful conversations—and meaningful conversations into loyal borrowers.